Camera Tricks & Credibility

There is more than the eye can see in opponents’ latest video

Image from video produced by Northern Pass opposition group

Image from video produced by Northern Pass opposition group

Actual current photo of playground and existing transmission corridor in same location

Last week, a Maine-based company called Conservation Media Group released a blatantly misleading video that uses heavily doctored images in an attempt to pressure Concord city officials into opposing the project. The video does not identify who is paying for the spot. The partners in this deceptive video are only revealed by clicking on a link and scrolling to the bottom of a separate page. These partners include the Society for the Protection of New Hampshire Forests and the Appalachian Mountain Club.

This is not the first time professional opposition groups have produced a misleading video, but it is arguably the most egregious. A number of sections of this video are inaccurate, misleading or manipulative, including shots where existing power lines were removed from the image.

Northern Pass has hired an independent firm to prepare professional view impact assessments as part of its New Hampshire Site Evaluation Committee approval process. The opposition groups that produced this latest video have made no effort to meet such professional standards.

Instead, and unfortunately, opponents have taken the unethical approach of doctoring photographs and misrepresenting facts in an attempt to further mislead the public. New Hampshire and the region face tremendous challenges in the cost of electricity, lack of fuel diversity, and dwindling energy supplies. Residents and ratepayers deserve better than to have those issues distorted for political or fundraising purposes.

Here are some examples of the deceptive nature of this latest video by opposition groups:

The Playground:

The scene that is apparently most intended to shock viewers also happens to be the most blatantly inaccurate. At the 42-second mark, we see a string of structures pop up around a small playground.

Image from video misleads viewer by digitally removing power lines that exist today

Image from video misleads viewer by digitally removing power lines that exist today

Image from video gives viewer the false impression that Northern Pass structures will be built in an area where power lines do not exist today

Image from video gives viewer the false impression that Northern Pass structures will be built in an area where power lines do not exist today

Truth is, as seen below in an undoctored image, that playground was built directly underneath several power lines that have been there for decades and are clearly visible today. These power lines do not appear in the video because the video producers deliberately photoshopped those lines out of the shot.

Actual photo of playground and existing transmission corridor

Actual photo of playground and existing transmission corridor

The Structures:

At the 15-second mark, a string of transmission structures pop up from the ground. These are not the same kind of structures that will be used in Concord, nor is it clear this land is even located in Concord. A factual representation of the Concord structures has been provided to Concord by Northern Pass and is posted on the city’s website. During the same scene, “1500 Towers” appears on screen, leaving the casual observer with the impression that this is the number of structures to be built in Concord. In fact, this is a reference to the total number of structures along the entire 187 mile Northern Pass proposed route. Not the 8.1 miles in Concord.

Image from video

Image from video

The Location of the Line:

The New Hampshire State House is shown at the 33-second mark as the video discusses possible impact to the city, however, the Northern Pass line will not be visible from the state Capitol grounds, nor from any portion of the downtown area. The closest the project will come to the State House is 2.3 miles, and that section of the project is within a commercially developed area.

Image from video

Image from video

Use of Locations Not Along the Route:

At both the 28 and 30-second marks of the video, the viewer is given the impression that the Northern Pass line will be visible from the Canterbury Shaker Village and the Tilton Arch in Northfield. Neither location is in Concord, as the text implies, and neither location will have a view of the Northern Pass line.

Image from video

Image from video

Image from video

Image from video

The Mystery Transmission Corridor:

The video also includes images of questionable origin, including at the 1:04-mark. While we cannot definitively say where this shot was taken, we do know this is not a right-of-way in New Hampshire.

Image from video shows unknown transmission corridor not affiliated with Northern Pass (structure design or location)

Image from video shows unknown transmission corridor not affiliated with Northern Pass (structure design or location)

Tucker’s Turn: Concord on YouTube

Posted in Feature | Comments Off

Seeking balance

The latest word from the region’s grid operator – the folks who keep the lights on and our phones charged up – is that New England made out OK this winter. ISO-NE’s winter operations summary finds a number of factors combined to keep the system in check, but it also warns that many uncertainties will likely contribute to high prices and supply constraints going forward.2012-2015_Wholesale Energy Market Value

These unknowns are in the background as utilities in New Hampshire and elsewhere announce lower energy service rates for the summer months – and they’re behind a major push by New England’s business leaders to advocate for new energy infrastructure projects.

Discussion around such projects goes beyond major proposals for natural gas pipelines and clean energy transmission. Policy makers across the region are contemplating the best way to incorporate both small and large scale renewable energy projects as New England strives for a secure and diverse energy mix.

 

New England power system performed well through winter 2014/2015
ISO Newswire, 7 April 2015

Electricity rates dropping in near term
Portsmouth Herald, 3 April 2015

Business leaders seek support from governors over energy projects
Union Leader, 9 April 2015

‘Relieving the Energy Crisis’ event set for April 17
NHBR, 7 April 2015

New England’s energy brokers must look beyond natural gas
Boston Globe, 9 April 2015

Maine governor: Wind power is too expensive
AP via Portsmouth Herald, 4 April 2015

Solar advocates say cap on incentives is blocking projects
Bourne Courier, 9 April 2015

Maine’s energy forecast: Partly sunny, clouded by questions
Portland Press Herald, 5 April 2015

 

Posted in Energy Brief | Comments Off

New England’s calls to action

Last week’s headlines indicate that the nation’s move toward new energy policies shows no sign of slowing down. The U.S. pledged to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by up to 28 percent. In New Hampshire, a new solar project is near completion, and yet this type of energy source still has some challenges to overcome before it can see long-term success in our neighboring states.

The debate over siting continues in Vermont and Massachusetts, despite continued arguments that energy infrastructure must be added to address the strain of ever-increasing energy costs. While there will continue to be questions about the hows and whys, we are seeing more elected officials, business leaders, opinion makers and others across the region call for solutions to these energy problems.

U.S. promises to cut greenhouse gas emissions by up to 28 percent by 2025
WBUR, 31 March 2015

Peterborough solar array to be completed next month
New Hampshire Union Leader, 2 April, 2015

Maine’s energy forecast: partly sunny, clouded by questions
Portland Press Herald, 5 April 2015

Mass solar projects could soon reach limit
Boston Globe, 30 March 2015

Lawmakers hear from both sides on energy siting policy
VT Digger, 25 March 2015

Politicians, activists demand federal regulators revoke pipeline approval
Boston Globe, 2 April 2015

My Turn: What we need is more supply
Concord Monitor, 1 April 2015

Energy is a big concern for Guinta
Conway Daily Sun, 1 April 2015

Posted in Energy Brief | Comments Off

The Numbers Don’t Lie

Utility Dive price chart

EIA information via Utility Dive shows the breakdown of retail electricity prices by region. The Pacific Noncontiguous region is made up of Hawaii and Alaska. New England is the highest in the contiguous 48 states.

No matter which way you look at it, electricity prices in New England are high. The cost of literally being at the end of the pipeline – and resisting efforts to expand the region’s energy supply – is adding up for both business owners and homeowners alike.

There is broad, general agreement that New England needs to tap into the abundance of both natural gas and hydroelectricity just outside of our region. Many believe that finding consensus on the best way to do that, together with incorporating local renewable energy projects, will finally begin to stabilize supply and lower prices.

 

5 charts that explain U.S. electricity prices
Utility Dive, 23 March 2015

Northeast, despite highest gas costs, resists more pipelines
AP via Concord Monitor, 29 March 2015

High utility costs irk businesses, politicians at Franklin roundtable
Milford Daily News, 28 March 2015

Lawmaker investigating massive utility rate hikes
My Fox Boston, 27 March 2015

Hydro-Quebec looking south to new markets
VT Digger, 24 March 2015

U.S., Canadian officials cite regional energy collaboration
AP via Concord Monitor, 23 March 2015

We need relief from energy stranglehold
Lowell Sun, 27 March 2015

Posted in Energy Brief | Comments Off

Northern Pass Joins Partnership to Protect N.H.’s Forests and Rivers

Northern Pass announced on Thursday it is part of a new effort that will bring more than $4.5 million in land conservation and restoration grants to New Hampshire. Called Partners for New Hampshire’s Fish and Wildlife, this program is aimed at restoring and sustaining healthy forests and rivers throughout the state.

From the beginning, Northern Pass has sought to form partnerships with local communities and organizations to support efforts that strengthen New Hampshire’s economy. We believe this new partnership represents a significant commitment to build NEcottontail1upon New Hampshire’s strengths as a place where wildlife can thrive.

Over the next two years, Partners for New Hampshire’s Fish and Wildlife will focus on supporting cost-effective, hands-on conservation projects around the state. Projects will be selected based on their ability to achieve long-term, measurable outcomes that meet the program’s goals. These goals include:

  • Strengthening the health of the forest system;
  • Sustaining working forests;
  • Improving the quality of streams;
  • Enhancing the biodiversity of New Hampshire’s fish and wildlife population.

Partners for New Hampshire’s Fish and Wildlife is the result of a partnership between the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation (NFWF) and Northern Pass’ parent company, Eversource. Northern Pass has committed $3 million to the partnership. NFWF and its funding partners are committing an additional $1.5 million, boosting the total conservation impact to at least $4.5 million. Through NFWF’s efforts, there is the potential for more funding from additional partners.

NFWF has already granted funding to two early action projects. In Londonderry and Dover, NFWF has granted $200,000 for protecting and rebuilding habitat for early successional species, or those animals that thrive in young forests, like the New England cottontail and the American woodcock. Overseen by the Wildlife Management Institute, the funding for this project will go toward restoring roughly 30 acres in both communities, as well as provide educational materials about the project to Londonderry High School and Middle School through the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s Schoolyard Habitat program.

In addition, the Connecticut River Watershed Council, Inc., will use a $180,000 grant toward its Eastern Brook Trout Aquatic Organism Passage project, which will reopen more than 10 miles of fish habitat in Haverhill and create 20 miles of interconnected habitat for the Eastern Brook Trout—a threatened species.

trout1

Other partners for these projects include New Hampshire Fish and Game Department, the Town of Londonderry, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Trout Unlimited, New Hampshire Charitable Foundation, and the Town of Haverhill.

In the coming two years, NFWF will continue to solicit additional grant applications from other projects around the state. The next round of proposals will be awarded this summer.

As the state’s largest proposed clean energy project, Northern Pass is proud to be part of a partnership that seeks to protect and strengthen our state’s most treasured and unique habitats. We look forward to seeing the results of the important conservation efforts that will be fostered by this partnership.

Posted in Environment, Feature, Press Releases | Comments Off

The path to prosperity

New Hampshire residents would largely agree that the entire state benefits when the economy is doing well, businesses are growing and people can find a job with a good wage. We’ve written here before about how business leaders across the state are worried our recovering economy is in jeopardy because of New Hampshire’s high energy costs. We saw that message again last week from a well-known New Hampshire policy expert, concerned our current energy policy could contribute to New Hampshire moving in the wrong direction.

Across the region, the debate over energy is advancing. Experts spend less time on whether more natural gas is needed in New England and more time on how best to get it here. Enthusiasm for solar energy has prompted the regional grid operator to adjust its forecast for the energy source, and in Maine, a $1.4 billion transmission line upgrade was recently completed that brought thousands of jobs and millions of dollars to the Maine economy. We still continue to debate the details when it comes to new energy sources, but there is a growing consensus when it comes to the need for new infrastructure.

 

Links:

Charlie Arlinghaus: For NH think long-term or fall behind
New Hampshire Union Leader

Pipeline opponents say LNG is underutilized
Boston Globe

More solar faster predicts New England grid operator
JD Supra Business Advisor

CMP nears completion of $1.4 billion power grid upgrade
Portland Press Herald

My Turn: Here’s the real story about hydropower in Quebec
Concord Monitor

Posted in Energy Brief | Comments Off

A season of change for energy

We saw last week that New England’s energy landscape is changing rapidly, from how power is made to how much we pay for it. Our state’s 12 utility-owned power plants will be going on the market, completing the two-decade long process of deregulating New Hampshire’s energy industry. Energy officials speculate these plants will be quickly purchased, as other existing power plants in neighboring New England states have been.

There was also discussion of the annual ISO New England Forward Capacity Auction, which will net power generators $4 billion in 2018-2019 – and add to New England’s continually rising electricity rates. Across the region, residents and elected officials continue to push for clean energy. A new study shows solar energy has a future in a state like Maine but, like other clean energy projects, the debate is over who pays for it.

Links:

New Hampshire to sell utility-owned power plants
Boston Globe

Give us your tired, your poor power plants
New Hampshire Union Leader

Deregulation behind payments to keep power plants online
New Hampshire Union Leader

Next four years of electricity costs looking bleak
New Hampshire Union Leader

Growth in residential electricity prices highest in 6 years, but expected to slow in 2015
EIA Today in Energy

The amazing effort to save Cape Win
Cape Cod Today

My Turn: Here’s the real story about hydropower in Quebec
Concord Monitor

The value of power: Solar goes sky-high in Maine
Portland Press Herald

New Maine wind farm reopens legal questions
Bangor Daily News

Posted in Energy Brief | Comments Off

Taking the long view

Just as some were declaring the region has overcome its energy challenges, the folks who run New England’s electrical grid issued a reality check last week. The 2015 Regional Electricity Outlook underscores the need for new energy infrastructure to ensure, “a reliable supply of competitively priced electricity…”

ne_elec

Data from the Energy Information Administration shows New England’s electricity rates to be consistently higher than the U.S. average. Courtesy EIA.gov

The long term presents inarguable and troubling trends for New England. Electricity rates have been higher here, on average, than anywhere else in the continental U.S. since 2003; and, despite a dip in wholesale prices this winter from last year’s historic highs, costs are projected to rise even more over the coming years.

The core reasons for this price pressure remain the same – too little fuel diversity and a lack of infrastructure to support New England’s electricity demands. These root causes won’t go away with temporary fixes, and failing to address them will have a major impact on the region’s economy.

 

Power Plant Owners Argue Energy ‘Crisis’ Is Overblown
NHPR, 4 March 2015

Fuel, Reliability Constraints for New England Grid
Electric Co-Op Today, 9 March 2015

2015 Regional Electricity Outlook
ISO-NE, 27 February 2015

New England Residential Electricity Rates Rise in 2013 and 2014
EIA.gov, 4 March 2015

Wholesale electricity costs won’t stay low forever
NHBR, 20 February 2015

Prices Rise in 2018/2019 New England Power Auction
Energy Manager Today, 4 March 2015

Power and prices weather the winter
CT Mirror, 6 March 2015

Kennedy keeps up protests against electric rate auction; columnist cites ‘price-gouging’
The Herald News, 2 March 2015

Business president: Electricity supplies key to lowering prices
Concord Monitor, 8 March 2015

Groups mull vision of economic development in NH
Union Leader, 3 March 2015

 

Posted in Energy Brief | Comments Off

Consider This

The New England Power Generators Association, or NEPGA, is echoing the false claim that the region’s energy crisis is over – that winter power prices are down compared to last year, market fixes have solved the problem, and major investment in new infrastructure isn’t needed. Their claims contradict the evidence before us and overlook the very real and expensive energy problem New England now faces. Before buying NEPGA’s claim, consider this…

The Truth about Prices
While it is accurate to say wholesale electricity prices in New England were down in January compared to the historic high the year before, the average price of wholesale power during the winter of 2014 was a whopping 94 percent more than in 2013. Prices this January were still a lot more than they were two years ago – 34 percent more, and preliminary data also suggests that this February’s wholesale prices were higher than two years ago. As we look to the future, the 1,500 megawatt Brayton Point power plant, which primarily burns coal and oil, will retire in June 2017, making New England’s gas dependency even higher and putting even more upward pressure on energy prices.

What’s overlooked in the reports about “lower energy costs this winter” is that New England customers continue to pay more for electricity than anywhere else in the country. According to data from the Energy Information Administration, homeowners here pay on average 5 cents per kilowatt hour more than the U.S. average. For a modest electricity user, that amounts to $300 extra a year.

Big Dollars at Stake
NEPGA’s members control more than 80 percent of all the existing power generation in New England. Every year generators pledge to produce power several years down the road in a process called the Forward Capacity Auction. The FCA guarantees payments to generators for this pledge, essentially a type of “incentive payment.” Electric utility customers in New England currently pay a total of $1 billion in annual capacity payments. The most recent auction results indicate that price tag will increase to $4 billion in three years.

Here in New Hampshire for instance, the owners of Seabrook Station will receive $45 million in capacity payments this year. The most recent auction results indicate that figure will increase to $127 million in 2018, and even more the following year. These increased capacity payments are the result of limited supply and looming power plant retirements that are shrinking our capacity supply. Generators receive bigger payments because when supply goes down prices go up.

Interestingly, these capacity payments are in addition to the money power generators will make on the electricity they produce. Without major solutions to address supply constraints, these capacity prices will stay high, and New England’s electric utility customers will continue to pay extra money to generators just to stay open.

Temporary is No Solution
In NEPGA’s recent press conference, speakers pointed to market responses that kept wholesale power prices from reaching record highs again this winter. Few of these responses, however, can be viewed as permanent fixes.

One such fix is ISO-New England’s Winter Reliability Program which offers potentially millions of dollars in incentives to power plants for storing extra fuel – like oil and Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) –as a backup if natural gas is unavailable or other problems strain the ability to produce power. The program is a temporary one and requires federal approval each year it’s proposed.

Another fix cited is this year’s increased supply of Liquified Natural Gas (LNG), which this winter was pumped into New England’s pipelines from off-shore ports. In recent years, LNG has gotten a higher premium in markets outside the US, but that changed this year. Low market prices for LNG worldwide have made New England an attractive market. While those shipments certainly helped to stabilize natural gas prices and supply this winter, there’s no certainty that prices will continue to be attractive enough to rely on future shipments.

There is a wide regional discussion about how to rein in New England’s out-of-control energy costs. Multiple studies point to a real problem that will only be solved by adding new energy infrastructure. Even our independent grid operator, ISO New England, is urging our region to increase our energy supply. Yet NEPGA’s members claim that there is no crisis. It’s no wonder, considering all they have to lose if New England really does solve its energy challenges.

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off

Keeping it in perspective

With spring just weeks away, we’re starting to get a sense of how much fuel was used to make electricity this winter and how much it cost. This year’s natural gas and electricity prices were not as high as last year, despite higher demand and one of the coldest Februarys on record. Unfortunately, New England is still paying the highest energy prices in the country.

New England natural gas prices between Jan. 1 and Feb. 20 traded at prices “four or more times higher than in the west.” The average price in California during that time

Courtesy: www.eia.gov, source: Natural Gas Intelligence

Courtesy: www.eia.gov, source: Natural Gas Intelligence

was $3.10 per million British thermal unit (MMBtu), but New England prices averaged above $10 MMBtu and climbed to $23.51/MMBtu on peak days. Power plants in New Hampshire were running throughout the cold, but natural gas supply constraints and price volatility were still factors.

The cost to produce power is also less than it was at this time last winter, but this has yet to translate into lower rates for residential customers, and prices continue to remain the highest in the continental U.S. For example, day-ahead wholesale electricity prices for Feb. 28 were trading at an average of $140.92 per megawatt hour, while in California, electricity futures were around $30. Efforts to lower these rates continue. The governors of Massachusetts, Connecticut and Rhode Island are joining together to increase use of renewable energy sources and expand natural gas capacity.

While some might argue New England has come out on the other side of its winter energy crisis, price data show the cost of natural gas and electricity remains high.

 

Links:

As New England freezes, natural gas stays cheap
Reuters

New England natural gas demand up over winter 2013/2014
Fierce Energy

Historically cold February in Concord doesn’t trigger spike in heating help
Concord Monitor

As record setting cold blasts the East, western temperatures warmer than normal
EIA Natural Gas Weekly

Eversource: you know its cold when…
Girard At-Large

Wholesale electric prices lower than expected but residential rates remain high
Boston Globe

Governors looking to expand renewable energy, natural gas
Daily Hampshire Gazette

Posted in Energy Brief | Comments Off